Main content
Finance and capital markets
Course: Finance and capital markets > Unit 9
Lesson 2: Forward and futures contracts- Forward contract introduction
- Futures introduction
- Motivation for the futures exchange
- Futures margin mechanics
- Verifying hedge with futures margin mechanics
- Futures and forward curves
- Contango from trader perspective
- Severe contango generally bearish
- Backwardation bullish or bearish
- Futures curves II
- Contango
- Backwardation
- Contango and backwardation review
- Upper bound on forward settlement price
- Lower bound on forward settlement price
- Arbitraging futures contract
- Arbitraging futures contracts II
- Futures fair value in the pre-market
- Interpreting futures fair value in the premarket
© 2023 Khan AcademyTerms of usePrivacy PolicyCookie Notice
Arbitraging futures contract
Created by Sal Khan.
Want to join the conversation?
- Where can I buy apples that last for a year?(17 votes)
- There are no contracts for apples on the futures markets, this was just used as an example for the video.(16 votes)
- in the last video he mentioned that carrying costs were significant in rational future prices, but there is no mention of carrying costs in this video. Why didn't he factor that in, since its just basic addition? if the carrying cost is $50, its still worthwhile to do the arbitrage scheme, still making $30 in risk free profit.(4 votes)
- guess it's because it doesn't cost anything to store apples but gold has to have a cost - to avoid theft(5 votes)
- But it is not that easy to borrow money from a bank right? Will a bank really lend you money to speculate in the futures market?(2 votes)
- Beyond that, most futures brokers offer margin accounts that will provide the credit to your account. But most have minimum deposits to open the account.(7 votes)
- Sal says that risk and reward almost have an opposite relationship. Sal claims that he can make a risk free profit, so does that mean the reward here isn't that high?(2 votes)
- When you are performing arbitrage, you are only able to do so because of an imbalance in the financial system. That means that the risk-reward tradeoff is not in place any more to the extent that it should. When people do arbitrage the system, though, it will restore that balance.(5 votes)
- How is this an example of risk-free action? There is risk that the product (apples in this hypothetical example) gets damaged, stolen etc. in the one year period between today and when the futures contract requires delivery. It seems to me that the reason the futures price would be higher than the spot price is because the market is valuing this risk at the difference between the two prices. So how is this arbitrage, which by definition is risk-free?(2 votes)
- You can insure the apples. You get an insurance company that has a AAA rating (defined as risk free on their financial commitments) to ensure the apples for loss or damage over the course of the year. As long as the cost of that insurance is less than $80, you still have a risk-free profit. This is part of the carrying cost that was mentioned in previous videos.(2 votes)
- Maybe it is not a quite related question, but could anyone tell me what is the differences between settlement price and delivery price? Thank you.(1 vote)
- The settlement price is the price at the end of each trading day, when everyone's accounts need to be settled (ie everyone needs to have a certain minimum amount of cash in his account, and that depends on the price). The delivery price is the price at which a transaction takes place at the expiration of the contract.(2 votes)
- Is this form of arbitrage possible for the average trader?(1 vote)
- Likely not - there are hundreds of firms with high powered computers and supply chains that execute arbitrages faster than the average retail trader would be able to. Unfortunately it's a pretty stacked game(1 vote)
- What is meant by "we sell the Futures short"? 1:37(1 vote)
- it means one is entering a forwards contact to sell some thing at a higher price in the future whilst betting that the spot price shall remain significantly lower than the agreed delivery price in order to make a profit.(1 vote)
- Is this the same thing as in Real Estate?
I get a ROI of 15% on an apartment building and the bank borrows me at 5%?(1 vote) - If I can sell the futures contract, then why should I even borrow money in the first place? Why not short the futures contract, getting $300, and then use the proceeds to buy $200 of apples, pocketing the difference? Is it because I need to hold some money in margin? This technique would allow me to make $100 instead of $80.(1 vote)
- It costs you money to store the apples, plus you have a probability of losing money on the contract. Maybe that is worth an extra $20 to you, or maybe it's not.
You also can't withdraw the entire $200 from your margin account.(1 vote)
Video transcript
Male voiceover: Let's say that the
current market settlement price for a Futures Contract
that specifies the delivery of a thousand pounds of
apples on October 20th and just for the simplicity
of the math in this example, let's assume that that is one year away and the current settlement
price, the current market price on the future exchange for
delivery on that date is $300. Let's also assume that
the current market price, if you were to buy or sell
apples today not on October 20th, which is a year away
but today, let's assume that the current market price is $200. Let's also assume that if you
were to take out a $200 loan that you would have to pay 10% interest. If you were to borrow $200 today, you would essentially have
to pay back $220 in a year. Now, given all of the
parameters that I've set up, is there a way to make risk-free profits? Is there way to kind of
arbitrage this situation? And as you can imagine, there is and what we can do is, we can borrow $200, Let me list it all out. We can borrow $200 and then use that $200 to buy 1,000 pounds of apples. Then we buy 1,000 pounds of apples. We keep them in our garage
or some place like that and then we also sell
or I guess we could say, we become the seller on
this Futures Contract or we sell the Futures short, I guess is another way to think about it. We also become the seller
on the Futures Contract. Essentially, we are agreeing
to sell 1,000 pounds of apples on October 20th, a year from now for $300. So I wanna show you is
if we set it up this way, we are guaranteed to make money no matter what happens to the price of apples and that's why we're
calling it an arbitrage because if you fast forward one year, so let's fast forward one year. In one year, we definitely
have 1,000 pounds of apples and just for the sake of simplicity, let's assume that apples don't get bad that I've somehow freeze-dried
them or I don't know. These are apples that never spoil. (chuckles) Let's say a year from now, I have the thousand pounds of apples so I give the apples to
settle the Futures Contract. Give apples to settle the contract and then of course, I have my loan. I have my loan of $200 but guess what? When I settled the contract, when I settled the Futures
Contract, I got $300. So, I get 300 dollars and what do I owe? Well, I owe $220 on my loan. Let me subtract that out. I owe $220 and so I made
a guaranteed risk-free $80 of profit in one year
and we're not thinking about how much money I might
have had to set aside for margin but this essentially, just free money and if you think about it, if this settlement price is anything, if the settlement price
is anything above the $220 then I'm going to make a risk-free profit. One way to think about
Futures pricing is even if you think there's
going to be a cold snap and apples are going to disappear and there's going to be
the shortage of apples and so you might say, "Hey,
maybe the apple prices "will go up." a year ago, there's always going to be a way to arbitrage it if the settlement price, if the growth in price
is more than the cost of borrowing the same amount of money, the cost of borrowing $200. In this situation, the
cost of borrowing is $20. The settlement price really shouldn't be, if we assume that there's
no arbitrage opportunities, it really shouldn't be more than $220.