Main content
Medieval Europe + Byzantine
Course: Medieval Europe + Byzantine > Unit 10
Lesson 3: Gothic art in France- Birth of the Gothic: Abbot Suger and the ambulatory at St. Denis
- St. Denis Ambulatory (quiz)
- Chartres Cathedral
- Cathedral of Notre Dame de Chartres (quiz)
- The Cathedral of Notre-Dame, Paris (before the fire)
- Reims Cathedral
- Reims Cathedral and World War I
- Amiens Cathedral
- Amiens cathedral
- Sainte-Chapelle, Paris
- Bible moralisée (moralized bibles)
- Saint Louis Bible (moralized bible)
- Humanizing Mary: the Virgin of Jeanne d’Evreux
- Jean le Noir, Bourgot (?), and workshop, Miniature of Christ’s Side Wound and Instruments of the Passion from the Prayer Book of Bonne of Luxembourg
- Ivory casket with scenes from medieval romances
© 2023 Khan AcademyTerms of usePrivacy PolicyCookie Notice
Reims Cathedral
Reims Cathedral (Cathédrale Notre-Dame de Reims), begun 1211, Reims, France. Speakers: Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker. Created by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker.
Want to join the conversation?
- I can see that the giant wooden doors at the entrance have smaller, regular sized doors cut into them. Were those regular sized doors always there? Or are they a modern addition, making an easier way to get in and out than opening the giant doors?(6 votes)
- they were created recently to create easier accsess(2 votes)
- Just wondering how they were able to identify the knight light statue as Abraham?(2 votes)
- Earlier records contained depictions of him. They matched up the correct descriptions and identified it as him(1 vote)
- I am not sure why but the exterior of the church, in particular the placement of the figures (not their style), reminds me of a Hindu temple. Was there any influence from India or artists gradually developed this style from the Romanesque and prior periods? My understanding that the world was a small place even in the Middle Ages and some kind of exchange of artistic ideas might occur.(2 votes)
- I wonder how much it would have cost to build a structure such as that.(1 vote)
- It cost the dedication and devotion of many people over a long period of time. I imagine, though, that you are asking about a monetary cost. In which currency would you like to have a response, and why would that matter, anyway?(2 votes)
Video transcript
(upbeat piano music) - [Steven] We're in the
square in the city of Reims in France looking at one of
the great Gothic cathedrals. - [Beth] Everything seems
to reach heavenward. - [Steven] It's pierced everywhere. - [Beth] As we look at it,
it hardly feels like stone, it has a weightlessness. - [Steven] This is a characteristic of the High Gothic period. - [Beth] We're not far from Paris, and in fact the great Gothic
and High Gothic churches form a circle around Paris. - [Steven] This period in
the 12th and 13th centuries was a period in which France was not the nation as we now know it. The Capetian monarchy, the king of France, was in control only of the Ile-de-France, the area that surrounds Paris. Beyond that, other feudal barons, lords, controlled large areas. - [Beth] But it's during
exactly this Gothic period that the Capetian monarchs
expand their territory, and increase their power. And one of the ways they do that is by cathedral building. - [Steven] A building like this doesn't spring out of nothing. This is based on centuries
of experimentation that we can see especially
in great Romanesque churches in the years after the
turn of the millennia. - [Beth] The desire to
build roofing out of stone that we see being in the Romanesque reaches a kind of perfection
during the Gothic. It's these developments in things like flying buttresses
and in the Groin Vault that allow the Gothic builder
to build so tall, so high, to pierce the walls in
the way that he does to allow light to enter the building. - [Steven] But all of
that is in the service of the spiritual, to use light symbolically
to create a space that is meant to
represent heaven on earth. - [Beth] Typically for both
Romanesque and Gothic churches we have a west front
which has three entrances. Generally, that reflects
the interior of the church. - [Steven] And these are called, portals. And they reflect the interior
because the central doors enter into the widest part
of building, the nave. And each of the side doors
open up into the side aisles. - [Beth] Beginning in
the Romanesque period, we begin to see figures on
either side of the doorway and above the doorway in a
space called the tympanum. The figures on either side,
they're called jamb figures. - [Steven] Because they're
attached to the door jams. And then surrounding the tympanum, almost like amplification of the shape, are archivolts. These radiate out and here
they create closed porches. - [Beth] They're quite deep. They create this funnel
that draws the visitor in. Now here at Reims, instead of sculpture, we have stained glass in the tympanum. The sculpture that we would
expect to see in the tympanum, is now above that in the gabled
spaces above the achivolts. - [Steven] Now just above the rose window in this central portal, there's another even larger rose. - [Beth] At this cathedral in particular, the artists have achieved an amazing thing with the stained glass windows. They've reduced that stone
that holds the glass in place to very fine tracery. It seems miraculous that that
glass is being held in place. - [Steven] And glass has even been added around the rose itself. And solid stone in earlier churches has here been opened up to
allow even more light in. On either side of the rose
window are two enormous towers, pierced throughout so that
light pours through them and they seem delicate. - [Beth] And then we have another feature which is typical of Gothic churches, in this case it's located
above the rose window, and this is called the Gallery of Kings. Here we have a row of Old Testament kings who are understood as
the ancestors of Christ. According to the New Testament, Christ traced his lineage back
to the house of King David. - [Steven] This is
called the tree of Jesse and that refers back to Jesse
the father of King David. But in this particular church at the center of the Gallery of Kings, we see the baptism of King Clovis, the man who begins the
ancient Merovingian Dynasty, a dynasty that the more
modern kings of France would have looked back to. - [Beth] What happened at
Clovis's baptism was a miracle. The oil required to anoint him during the coronation
ceremony was miraculously received by the Bishop
from a dove sent by God. - [Steven] That legend is important because this is the Cathedral where the coronation
ceremonies took place, where the kings of France
received their divine inspiration, their divine power. - [Beth] So let's go take a closer look at the central doorway. What strikes me most of all as we approach any of these the three doorways is how animated the jam figures are. They tilt their heads,
they move their bodies. Many of them look down at us. It feels as if they're alive, and if we imagine that
they were once painted, that would have enhanced
their realism to any visitor walking through these portals. - [Steven] But if they were
real, they were giants. These are large sculptures. - [Beth] Significantly
larger than life-size. - [Steven] We've walked
into the central portal and we're looking at the jam figures that are on the right side. We have two scenes. On the left is the Annunciation, we see the Angel Gabriel
and the Virgin Mary. The Annunciation is the moment
when the Archangel Gabriel visits Mary with the news
that she will bear Christ. - [Beth] And on the right we see a scene known as the Visitation when Mary's cousin Elizabeth visits. They are both pregnant, Elizabeth is pregnant with
Saint John the Baptist. And of course Mary is pregnant
with the Christ child. - [Steven] When you look at
these two pairs of sculptures, you can see that they were
carved at different times and in very different styles. - [Beth] This is a big
undertaking to build a cathedral. Not only would you have
to have many masons who are cutting and carving stone, but also many sculptors who are working likely coming from different
workshops in the region. And so it makes sense that
you might have sculptures that are stylistically different. And here at Reims especially, we know that sculptures were moved from different locations on the building. And so it's not quite as
coherent as we might see at another Gothic church,
like Amiens, for example. - [Steven] Well, look at
the figures on the right. They look so classical. They're wearing drapery
that at first glance seems as if it could
come from ancient Rome. - [Beth] Right, and that's what
we mean by classical-looking back to the cultures of ancient
Greece and ancient Rome. And we know that Reims was an
important ancient Roman city. There are ancient Roman ruins here that may have been an
important source of inspiration for the sculptors who did
the scene of the Visitation. - [Steven] So much so that
earlier art historians thought for a time that
these might actually be antique sculptures from ancient Rome. - [Beth] What makes
them look so classical, so ancient Greek or Roman is that clinging drapery. We could think back to the sculptures on the Parthenon for example. - [Steven] And like those
ancient Greek sculptures we see attention to the
bodies below the drapery. When we look at Mary, we see her right knee projecting out, a traditional way of representing the body that we call contrapposto where her weight is largely on her left leg in this case. - [Beth] However one of
the tips that tells us this is not classical,
but is in fact Gothic, is that that sway in her hip that forms an S curve in
her body is exaggerated. And that's something we do see quite often in high Gothic sculpture. - [Steven] This is a characteristic that was considered quite elegant and part of the courtly culture especially of 12th and
13th century France. - [Beth] In early Gothic
sculpture when we had jam figures, there was a very close association between the figures and
the columns behind them. But here the figures seem
to almost have nothing to do with the columns behind them. They're very independent. The figures interact with one another. There's a sense of freedom
from the architecture, so that we almost read these
as freestanding sculptures. - [Steven] Lets take a
look at the Annunciation. It's not just that this pair contrast with the classicism of the Visitation, but the figures are
different from each other. - [Beth] And so we seem to have actually these two pairs of sculptures, the hands of three different sculptors. Compared to the figures around her, Mary seems very simple. She might hark back to
an earlier Gothic style. Her drapery is primarily these lines that fall straight down toward her feet. We have very little sense of a
body underneath that drapery. - [Steven] She reminds us of the more columnar figures at Chartres. although she has more mass, she has more solidity,
she's more of this world. - [Beth] But look at how
kindly her face appears, gentle, generous. Mary is understood as an intercessor as someone who intercedes
between human beings and the divine. As someone who appeal to Christ and help ensure our place in heaven. - [Steven] And that is
beautifully represented by the angel to her left. This is Gabriel announcing to Mary that she will bear Christ. And in this case the angel is represented with anatomy that seems otherworldly. The head is quite small,
the body is lyrical, the carving is incredibly delicate, and Mary seems earthly in comparison. - [Beth] He is very elongated, a very thin graceful neck. The way he pulls up his drapery seems like a very refined
member of the court in Paris. Art historians believe this is the latest of these four figures. - [Steven] The original paint, the original polychromy is still visible. This is a reminder that
all of these figures would have been brightly-painted. - [Beth] That lovely angelic smile, that other worldly smile. The puffing of the skin around the eyes, the delicate curls of the hair. These are features that we see in other sculptures from this time period. - [Steven] And that we can see in other jam figures on this church. If we turn around to the left
side of the central portal, we see especially the
figure known as Joseph carved in a style that is
very similar to the angel. - [Beth] And last but not least, we have a figure in the center as we look toward the doorway, this is called the trumeau
which supports the lintel. And here we see a very
atypically Gothic sculpture of Mary holding the Christ child, supporting him on her hips
with that sway of drapery. - [Steven] And as a
reminder that this church was closely associated
with the Capetian monarchy, she wears a large crown. So there is this immediate association between temporal and divine power. - [Beth] And as we stand in this doorway about to walk into the church, I'm reminded of the medieval visitors who would have looked up and seen figures that they were familiar with. They would have heard
sermons about these figures. They were have heard chants and songs. And in many ways these
figures were alive for them as we enter the church. - [Steven] We've entered
into the cathedral. We've walked past the
nave to the side aisle. And we're looking now across
at the interior elevation. - [Beth] This is a very typical elevation for a Gothic cathedral. We have the nave arcade, the row of arches that we see
on either side of the nave, and we notice that they're pointed which is a very typical
feature of Gothic architecture. And then above that we see a triforium. - [Steven] Now above
that is the clerestory, these soaring windows. In this case two very tall lancet windows. And above the lancets,
a small lobed window that looks like a small rose. - [Beth] Sometimes called an oculus. And here even in the
spaces between the lancets, even there we have glass. So this idea of opening
up as much of the walls as possible to the glass, now that's a really difficult feat when you have a stone vaulted ceiling. - [Steven] Which weighs
a tremendous amount, and which exerts tremendous
pressure downward and out and all that needs to be supported. Part of the brilliance of the Gothic is the understanding that
that weight can be born not entirely inside the
church with massive piers, but much of that weight
can be drawn outside and supported by flying buttresses that allow for light to come
into the church unobstructed. - [Beth] If we go back to the Romanesque, those stone vaulted ceilings were carried by these massive heavy walls. And along with the flying buttress that allows Gothic architects
to open up the walls to allow for this light is the use of the ribbed groin vault. - [Steven] Let's start at the bottom. We have large piers visually made lighter by the addition of these engaged columns, what are called colonnettes, that rise delicately up and that continue the entire
length of the elevation, all the way up to the
center of the vaulting. A groin vault is the intersection
of two barrel vaults. The Romanesque was in love with the idea of taking a Roman arch
and extending it in space to create a barrel vault. But what happens when you intersect at 90 degrees, two barrel vaults? You get a curved X shape
that's known as a groin vault. - [Beth] One of the
benefits of the groin vault is that it allows the weight
to come down on two points, instead of continuous walls, and that allows one to open up the space. - [Steven] In this case,
the vaulting is four-part. And at the intersection
of those four parts, we have ribbing that was an important
architectural innovation that allows for much of the
work of holding up the building to be taken by that ribbing rather than the webbing in between. Gothic architects often
used a type of stone that was lighter for
that in-between space. - [Beth] And as we look down
the aisle at the ribbing, we see this lovely pattern
creating linear decoration. - [Steven] The linear is seen
everywhere in the interior, but we also have it interrupted by beautiful decorative
passages that are foliate, that is that show foliage, leaves. We see it at the top of columns. And we also see it separating
some of the sculpture on the interior west wall. The fact that architecture
is purposefully using light as a symbolic expression of the divine is quite extraordinary. Light can pass through glass. It is magical substance. And here architects are weaving it into the very fabric of the building. - [Beth] To give us a
sense of the heavenly. One of the things that
distinguishes this cathedral from others from this period is that we're missing so much
of the original stained glass. This city was heavily
bombed during World War I and the cathedral sustained real damage that took decades to rebuild. - [Steven] That's most
evident in the destruction of some of the sculpture on
the exterior of the building, but also in the loss of the original glass in the clerestory, in the nave. What the destruction of World War I afforded the church was
the opportunity though for modern artists, most
notably Mark Chagall, to create new windows for the church. And we see a set of
gorgeous lancet windows in the axial chapel, the back most chapel in the church. - [Beth] We've walked back
down toward the west end toward the entrance, and we're immediately
faced by this unusual and fabulously beautiful sculpted wall. We're looking at dozens
of figures in small niches that surround the rose window. - [Steven] And this screen
frames each of the three portals. And it's interesting to
note that the subjects that are represented on
the interior west front, reflect the subjects on
the exterior portals. - [Beth] One can imagine the king after the coronation ceremony, after the King is imbued
with divine power, turning around to process
out of this doorway and looking at the very
scenes we're looking at today. - [Steven] And two of the
most prominent niches, just to the right of the main portal, reflect the relationship between the church and the king. We have two Old Testament figures, Melchizedek and Abraham. - [Beth] Both are dressed in
the garb of the Middle Ages, so we might not immediately
recognize Abraham because he's dressed as a knight. - [Steven] And although
Melchizedek and Abraham were kings, here in his knightly garb, Abraham represents the monarchy. - [Beth] And to his left, Melchizedek from the Old Testament who is both a king and a priest and he's administering
bread and wine to Abraham. - [Steven] And it's a reminder that in the 12th and 13th centuries, in fact for the entire medieval period, there is a complex relationship between the church and the king, between spiritual and temporal power. - [Beth] You have a king coming here to be anointed, to be crowned as king--
- By the church. - [Beth] By the Archbishop. So there's that sense in which the Archbishop is empowering the king. On the other hand, the
king once he's anointed during the coronation ceremony becomes God's vehicle on earth to protect and care for his kingdom. So you do have this almost coequal powers during the Middle Ages. Here I think exemplified
by the pair of figures of Melchizedek and Abraham. - [Steven] Melchizedek
reaches towards Abraham. Abraham, his hands together in prayer, bends forward towards Melchizedek and it's almost as if
the architectural frame that surrounds each disappears. - [Beth] And yet, we're drawn to that beautiful foliage pattern that surrounds each of these niches. A reminder of how
important the natural world was becoming during the Gothic period. This is a time of renewed interest in the philosophy of Aristotle, but also renewed interest in nature. - [Steven] Make no mistake,
this is not the Renaissance, but there are focused
moments of naturalism in medieval sculpture and we see that here in the representation of the oak, of some of the vines, as a framing motif. - [Beth] All of this in the service of understanding the world, the universe that God created for us, and the vehicle of the
church for our salvation. - [Steven] The church
is still breathtaking. One can only imagine how miraculous it must've seemed to
somebody in the 13th century.