During the Progressive Era, intrepid reporters exposed misdeeds in business and poor living conditions in American cities.
- Muckrakers were journalists and novelists of the Progressive Era who sought to expose corruption in big business and government.
- The work of muckrakers influenced the passage of key legislation that strengthened protections for workers and consumers.
- Some of the most famous muckrakers were women, including Ida Tarbell and Ida B. Wells.
“I aimed at the public’s heart, and by accident I hit it in the stomach.” So lamented Upton Sinclair, author of the novel The Jungle, a fictionalized account of the corruption and contamination in Chicago’s meatpacking industry. Sinclair was one of the most famous muckrakers of the Progressive Era, and had written The Jungle in 1905 to raise public awareness of the exploitation and foul conditions to which workers in the meatpacking industry were subjected.
Ironically, however, what concerned readers the most was not the trials and tribulations of the exploited industrial worker, but the novel’s description of meat contamination. The public outcry helped lead to the passage of the Meat Inspection Act and Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906, both of which established federal regulatory power over the food and drug industries.
Background to the Progressive Era
The Progressive Era (1890s-1920s) in US history was a period of intense social and political reform. Progressive reformers sought to expand the regulatory power of the federal government in order to expose corruption, eliminate unfair business practices, and improve society. Progressive reformers shared a faith in the power of government to redress social ills and a belief that human nature could be improved.
Industry tycoons like John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie had been criticized for amassing vast quantities of wealth at the expense of the working man. The Progressive Era witnessed the rise of labor unions, which sought to promote the interests of workers against the powerful business, corporate, and banking magnates. Other advocacy groups arose in this period to demand protections not just for labor, but for women, children, consumers, and the natural environment as well.
Muckrakers were an important part of this movement.
Raking the muck: exposing corruption in big business and government
The term “muckraker” was popularized in 1906, when Theodore Roosevelt delivered a speech suggesting that “the men with the muck rakes are often indispensable to the well being of society; but only if they know when to stop raking the muck . . ."
In this context, “raking the muck” refers to the practices of investigative journalists and activists who brought the unpleasant “muck” of corruption in government and big business to the surface.
Some of the most famous Progressive muckrakers were women. Ida Tarbell, a teacher, author, and journalist, published a series of articles in McClure’s Magazine in 1902. These articles became the foundation for her book, The History of the Standard Oil Company, which was published in 1904, and depicted Standard Oil tycoon John D. Rockefeller as a greedy, miserly monopolist. The book quickly became a bestseller and established Tarbell as an early pioneer of investigative journalism.
Ida B. Wells, an African American journalist and suffragist, was another influential female muckraker. She had been born into slavery in Mississippi in 1862, and in the 1890s became involved in anti-lynching activism. In 1892, she published Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in all its Phases, which detailed the systematic disenfranchisement of Southern blacks and even some poor whites. Wells was very influential in the early movement for civil rights, and was one of the founders of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People in 1909.
Muckrakers also sought to raise awareness of poverty and other social ills associated with industrialization. Jacob Riis, a Danish immigrant and photojournalist, published an eighteen-page photo essay called How the Other Half Lives: Studies among the Tenements of New York, which appeared first in the February 1889 issue of Scribner's magazine, and the following year was published as a book. The photos documented the harsh living conditions of recent immigrants in New York City and inspired reforms such as the New York Tenement House Act of 1901, which required tenement housing to be cleaner, safer, and more spacious.
What do you think?
Why do you think women played such an important role as muckrakers?
Why do you think muckrakers emerged during the Progressive Era and not in a different period of US history?
What were the goals and strategies of muckrakers? Were they successful?
Are there any muckrakers today? If so, who?
Want to join the conversation?
- What's the difference between suffragists and suffragettes?(16 votes)
- Suffragists believed in constitutional campaigning, whereas suffragettes believed in more direct action, for example, their motto was "Deeds not Words".(27 votes)
- Why do Muckrakers have a very unpositive name, yet did very positive things(10 votes)
- they "raked up" negative stuff about trusts and corporations. "muckrakers" is a kind of misleading term in terms of their legacies.(20 votes)
- What other books did Upton Sinclair write that "exposed" american industries?(11 votes)
- Upton Sinclair wrote over 100 books, both fiction and non-fiction. He was dedicated to exposing the social and economic conditions of his time.
In addition to The Jungle, based on the meatpacking industry, he also wrote critiques of the following industries:
The Brass Check
- journalism & the "free press"
King Coal and The Coal War
- coal industry & John D. Rockefeller, Jr.
- oil industry
- later adapted into the 2007 film There Will Be Blood
The Flivver King
- auto industry & Henry Ford
Hope this helps!(14 votes)
- If Muckrakers were historically the people who brought up government/big business corruption, is someone like Edward Snowden an example of a modern day Muckraker ?(9 votes)
- I would say so. But in a different way because in the Progressive Era these muckrakers were ousting only businesses and seeking help from the government while the Snowden incident involves the ousting of the government and its agencies. All in all however, I'd say you're right on the nose!(12 votes)
- Why do you think muckrakers emerged during the Progressive Era and not in a different period of US history?(5 votes)
- there is not really a reason why.. my guess is that robber barons want to get rich so that means to limit cost of manufactuaring. Also, there was a lot of immigration so less space for housing. Then, people are just racist,hence the lynching. Maybe people saw the bad and followed their hero..the president. This was a time that the president was looked up to and respected.(7 votes)
- In association with the well-defined purpose of the Progressive era thereof, muckrakers were crucial groups who could expose the ills, corruption, or other unfair activities in the businesses' tycoons. It was important that this era was corrupted by several aspects such as, getting advantages at the expense of the poor which looked awful. Muckraking-wise, this action aimed to uncover all corrupted activities of magnates' businesses, especially a well-known magnate- Andrew Carnegie- had been a so-called miserly monopolist during that epoch. Having said that, they were. Exposing the bad acts of greedy magnates, Ida, teacher, author, was brave to raise some problems , for instance, poverty, social ills to society.(8 votes)
- how did the muckrakers historically impact society in the 1900s(3 votes)
- Is this your homework, Malak? Or, did you just not listen to the lesson? If it's your homework, you should do it yourself. If you didn't understand this the first time you listened, you might try one more time.(5 votes)
- How exactly did the muckrakers influence politics and government? Was it just the force for change and exposure or were there more direct examples?(4 votes)
- What does Theodore Roosevelt mean when he said that journalists should know when to stop "raking the muck"?
Didn't he want for the journalists to expose more corruption?(3 votes)
- Theodore Roosevelt was an upper-class New Yorker. Many industrialists of his day were from the same sort of background. When journalists exposed the corruption in industry, they were offending Roosevelt's childhood neighbors and college classmates. Roosevelt may have appreciated what was exposed by the journalists, but he didn't want his friends, neighbors and classmates to be seen as "less than exemplary people." He wanted the exposure in the press to stop.(3 votes)
- How harsh were the living conditions back in the past?(3 votes)
- Living conditions throughout most of human history were nasty and brutish. Human life throughout most of human history was short.
Remember those terms together: nasty, brutish and short.
(Sounds like a Law Partnership, doesn't it?)(2 votes)