In the third century BCE, between the Greek-influenced Seleucid Empire and the Indian Mauryan Empire lay a small and prosperous kingdom called Bactria. This video is about cultural syncretism—the blending of cultures. What kinds of culture emerges at the crossroads of empire? Let's find out together, as we learn about Greco-Buddhism and Nestorian Christianity.
Want to join the conversation?
- Are there any examples, from history in general, where cultural syncretism was (is) intentionally suppressed/frowned upon, excluding overt religious suppression?(5 votes)
- There are definitely plenty of examples of this throughout history. To give just one, Japan closed its borders to the outside world - with the exception of a small amount of trade with nearby countries such as China - for over 200 years, specifically to avoid becoming westernized like the countries around it.(12 votes)
- What is Nestorian Christianity and how did it find it's way to China?(7 votes)
- According to the Syncretism article following this video, Nestorianism is "... a branch of Christianity branded as heresy—out of line with accepted teachings—by both the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches. Nestorians held that Jesus Christ was composed of distinct human and divine natures." According to Wikipedia, Nestorian Christianity can sometimes refer to members of the Church of the East, even if they do not necessarily believe in the Nestorius' teaching of a disunion between Jesus' human and divine natures.(7 votes)
- Isn't cultural syncretism the same as cultural diffusion- the mix and exchanging of ideas?(5 votes)
- Cultural Syncretism is when two different cultures blend together to create an amalgamation, for lack of better words, of the two cultures. Cultural Diffusion is, as you said, the exchanging of ideas, such as two countries bringing different types of food or innovations/inventions to each other. Hopefully this answers your question!(5 votes)
- So, can we say Hinduism is an example of religious syncretism over a long period of time?(4 votes)
- Personally, I would definitely say so...It was mainly influenced by Buddhism, which was established many years after the Hinduism. We always have to keep in mind that Buddhism was created as a reform for Hinduism, and if the state of Hinduism nowadays is compared to the state of Hinduism before Buddhism one can notice a great change, especially in a way castes are viewed today...
Nonetheless, eventually Hinduism "wiped" Buddhism out of India...(3 votes)
- [David] Hello historians and welcome to South Central Asia circa 280 BCE. We're looking at two empires that occupied some of the same area. We've got the Mauryan Empire here. You can see that this is the expansion that took place under Ashoka around 250 BCE. The Mauryan Empire encompasses the Indus River Valley. This is today what is Pakistan. Over here, we've got this region that is known as Gandara which is actually we think what the name Kandahar in Afghanistan comes from today. What we've got here is this intersection between two empires. We've got the Seleucid Empire over here in orange. These are, remember the remnants, this is one of three remnants of the empire of Alexander the Great. His general, Seleucus, took this part of Asia Minor, stretching into Central Asia. This is the extent of that empire around 280 BCE. What happens in 250 BCE is that a satrapy of the Seleucid Empire called Bactria secedes. It fights a war of independence to establish itself as its own kingdom. This is what we call the Greco-Bactrian kingdom. This is around 250 BCE. It names itself Bactria, after the great city of Bactra which gives it name to Afghanistan's Balkh province and up here on the northeast, you can see the city of Fergana which is today in Uzbekistan. If you remember from the article about the Silk Road, this is the very same Fergana where the Han Chinese first encountered those heavenly horses that sweated blood. What I wanna talk about is the culture of this purple region of Greco-Bactria because for many hundreds of years, this region had been passed back and forth between Indian powers and Macedonian powers. It has Hellenic influences and it also has Indian influences. That means we're gonna be talking about something called cultural syncretism. Let me put that down right here in the middle of China. Cultural syncretism. What syncretism is is a mixing of cultural objects. That's really it. It's the mixture of cultures and ideas and faiths. Follow me over here because I am interested in talking about the influence that Greek culture had on Buddhism and vice versa. These are two representations of the Buddha from around the same time, and in fact, from around the same region, the region of Gandara near modern-day Kandahar. So, within the kingdom of Bactria that we saw. Sandwiched between Hellenic influences and Indian influences. Both of these works are from the 1st Century CE. But let's talk about this footprint because this was a pretty common way to depict the Buddha prior to the 1st Century CE. We see, this is what's called an aniconic representation. This represent a footprint of the Buddha. You can see here some of the themes of Hinduism and Buddhism, so we've got this dharmachakra wheel in the center of the sole. We've got triratnas here near the heel. We've got, as you can see them very faintly, little swastikas near the metatarsals yonder. And these are all Buddhist or Hindu symbols that approach depicting the Buddha but do not actually put the Buddha into any kind of human physical representation. It's more about what the Buddha has left behind so that human beings can follow in his footsteps. But around the same time in the same region we see this. This is a statue. This is the standing Gandara Buddha. This again dates from the 1st Century CE from the same region of Bactria. But you can see this is the Buddha wearing Greek clothing. This is a Greek chiton and that's a himation. These are forms of Greek dress and the Buddha is being depicted in a Greek style. This is very similar to the other sculpture that we're seeing coming out of Hellenistic cultures at the same time. And so what we see when we see this Gandara Buddha, the standing Buddha, we have the combination of Buddhist faith or Buddhist philosophy combining with Greek cultural aesthetics. Indeed, Buddhism was practiced in this region for many hundreds of years. Since if you recall, let's go back to the map, because you're recall that Fergana and Bactria and all of these cities throughout Central Asia, Kandahar is back down here, are on the Silk Road that connect the world of what's called as the west shore to China. Through Fergana and through Bactria, you could get to the great centers of India. You can get to Pataliputra and Suvarnagiri and have access to the sea routes of trade. Many historians believed that it is through the cities of the Greco-Bactrian kingdom that Buddhism made its way along the Silk Road to the various oasis cities of Central Asia, and from then on, into China. We see syncretism whenever cultures combine with one another. And it is said that when Alexander the Great came to the head waters of the Indus River Valley, remember this is in upper Pakistan, he brought many philosophers with him to meet with the great thinkers of the Hindu ascetic tradition. These, the Greeks called the Gymnosophists, which means the naked thinkers because these men were so devoted to the practice of philosophy that they fasted and they wore either no or very little clothing because they felt that it got in the way of their pursuit of knowledge and wisdom. And if you make a study of Greek philosophy, you will see the impact that these Indian thinkers had on Greek philosophy during this period as well. Let's talk about some other examples of syncretism. This right here is the Nestorian Stele or rather this is a rubbing of the Nestorian Stele. This is a giant limestone block that was erected in 781 in Chang'an, the imperial capital of the Tang Empire in China. Celebrating 150 years of Nestorian Christianity. If you look very closely, you can see this little cross up here. There you go. There's your Nestorian cross, see right there. You can see all these Chinese text that symbolizes the important connection of the Church of the East to Tang China. What's interesting about this stone monument is the way in which Christianity is described within it. In order to proselytize to a Chinese population, Nestorian Christianity adapted its approach to suit the mores of the people that lived there. In this text, Christ is described in Daoist and Buddhist terms. Let me read you a little bit of the translation. "A virgin gave birth to the holy one in Syria. "A bright star announced the felicitous event "and Persians observing the splendor "came to present tribute. "The ancient dispensation is declared "by the 24 holy men was then fulfilled. "And he laid down great principles "for the government and families and kingdoms." They're talking about the messiah here. "He established the new religion of the "silent operation of the pure spirit of the Triune. "He rendered virtue subservient to direct faith. "He fixed the extent of the eight boundaries." Now, we're getting into some concepts from Mahayana Buddhism. "Thus completing the truth and freeing it from dross. "He opened the gate of the three constant principles." Again, these are Buddhist concepts. The impermanence, suffering, and non-self. "Introducing life and destroying death. "He suspended the bright sun to invade "the chambers of darkness, "and the falsehood of the devil were thereupon defeated. "He set in motion the vessel of mercy "by which to ascend to the bright mansions. "Whereupon rational beings were then released, "having thus completed the manifestation of his power, "in clear day he ascended to his true station." You can see the way that Buddhist thought is being used to contextualize Christianity, and really, that's what syncretism is all about. It's about taking a new idea, this thing, and putting it in line with this stuff, the eight boundaries, the constant principles, freeing the truth from dross. What these Nestorian missionaries were attempting to do was take these Christian principles and recast them in a Buddhist or Daoist light. Taking something and recasting it to fit the context of a new situation. You can learn anything. David out.