Why do we often need to follow these two rules when solving the exercises? 1) The denominator of the derivative must equal 0. 2) The numerator of the derivative must not equal 0. I don't get it, especially letting the denominator equal zero.

If a curve has a vertical asymptote at 𝑥 = 𝑐, then the slope of the tangent line (i.e. the derivative) there is ±∞, which means that the denominator of the derivative approaches zero as 𝑥 approaches 𝑐, while the numerator approaches a non-zero number. – – – In the video we are given the curve 𝑥² + 𝑦⁴ + 6𝑥 = 7 and its derivative 𝑑𝑦∕𝑑𝑥 = −2(𝑥 + 3)∕(4𝑦³) So, to find where the curve has a vertical asymptote we need to find the 𝑥-value/s for which the denominator of the derivative is zero, while the numerator isn't – that is 𝑦 = 0 and 𝑥 ≠ −3 We do this by solving the equation 𝑥² + 0 + 6𝑥 = 7, which gives us 𝑥 = −7 or 𝑥 = 1 – – – EDIT (12/3/2022) – – – The numerator can approach zero, as long as the denominator approaches zero faster. For example 𝑓(𝑥) = 𝑥²∕𝑥³ has a vertical asymptote at 𝑥 = 0 even though 𝑓′(0) = 0∕0.

Why is it that sometimes the numerator can not be zero and then other times it has to be zero? It shouldn't matter which one is Zero because zero divided by a number or a number divided by zero will still give you a dy/dx of zero. Also, what are you supposed to do when the tangent line is the y axis? Then, the derivative would be undefined since it would have a vertical slope.

"because zero divided by a number or *a number divided by zero will still give you a dy/dx of zero*." This is incorrect, a number divided by zero is undefined, which would give a vertical slope. Thus, when we are trying to find when the slope is vertical, (parallel to the y axis), we set the denominator equal to 0, which means that the derivative *must be undefined* (vertical slope). When we want to find the horizontal line, we set the numerator equal to zero, which means that the derivative *must equal zero* (horizontal slope).

How do you know that the initial curve is a circle?

It isn't a circle, but it is a closed loop. You can see this if you parameterize the curve as x(t)=4cos(t)-3 y(t)=√|4sin(t)| ·sin(t)/|sin(t)| The sin(t)/|sin(t)| factor makes y(t) negative when sin(t) is negative, so that you get both halves of the loop. Because we've expressed the curve in terms of sine and cosine, periodic functions, a particle tracing the path of the curve will repeat every 2π. Because the path repeats, it must form a loop.

Main content

Differential Calculus

Course: Differential Calculus > Unit 5

Lesson 12: Analyzing implicit relations

Horizontal tangent to implicit curve

Name: Horizontal tangent to implicit curve
Uploaded: 2018-08-13T08:08:48Z
Description: Finding the equation of a horizontal tangent to a curve that is defined implicitly as an equation in x and y.

AP.CALC:

FUN‑4 (EU)

FUN‑4.D (LO)

FUN‑4.D.1 (EK)

FUN‑4.E (LO)

FUN‑4.E.1 (EK)

FUN‑4.E.2 (EK)

Google Classroom

Finding the equation of a horizontal tangent to a curve that is defined implicitly as an equation in x and y.

Want to join the conversation?

Sort by:

avedantham
Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to avedantham's post “What happen if you had a ...”
What happen if you had a variable another than x in the numerator, such as y?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(25 votes)
Answer
- Ethan Colgan
  Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to Ethan Colgan's post “Solve the numerator for y...”
  Solve the numerator for y to find an equation for when the derivative is equal to zero. Substitute this equation for y into the original equation to find where the equation has a derivative equal to zero (horizontal tangent).
  Button navigates to signup page
  (1 vote)
Guilherme
Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to Guilherme's post “Why do we often need to f...”
Why do we often need to follow these two rules when solving the exercises?
1) The denominator of the derivative must equal 0.
2) The numerator of the derivative must not equal 0.
I don't get it, especially letting the denominator equal zero.
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(7 votes)
Answer
- Jerry Nilsson
  Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to Jerry Nilsson's post “If a curve has a vertical...”
  If a curve has a vertical asymptote at 𝑥 = 𝑐,
  then the slope of the tangent line (i.e. the derivative) there is ±∞,
  which means that the denominator of the derivative approaches zero as 𝑥 approaches 𝑐, while the numerator approaches a non-zero number.
  
  – – –
  
  In the video we are given the curve 𝑥² + 𝑦⁴ + 6𝑥 = 7
  and its derivative 𝑑𝑦∕𝑑𝑥 = −2(𝑥 + 3)∕(4𝑦³)
  
  So, to find where the curve has a vertical asymptote we need to find the 𝑥-value/s for which the denominator of the derivative is zero, while the numerator isn't – that is 𝑦 = 0 and 𝑥 ≠ −3
  
  We do this by solving the equation 𝑥² + 0 + 6𝑥 = 7,
  which gives us 𝑥 = −7 or 𝑥 = 1
  
  – – – EDIT (12/3/2022) – – –
  The numerator can approach zero, as long as the denominator approaches zero faster.
  For example 𝑓(𝑥) = 𝑥²∕𝑥³ has a vertical asymptote at 𝑥 = 0 even though 𝑓′(0) = 0∕0.
  Comment on Jerry Nilsson's post “If a curve has a vertical...”
  (21 votes)
Arabella Hunter
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Arabella Hunter's post “Why is it that sometimes ...”
Why is it that sometimes the numerator can not be zero and then other times it has to be zero? It shouldn't matter which one is Zero because zero divided by a number or a number divided by zero will still give you a dy/dx of zero. Also, what are you supposed to do when the tangent line is the y axis? Then, the derivative would be undefined since it would have a vertical slope.
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(3 votes)
Answer
- Marie Bethell
  Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to Marie Bethell's post “"because zero divided by ...”
  "because zero divided by a number or a number divided by zero will still give you a dy/dx of zero."
  
  This is incorrect, a number divided by zero is undefined, which would give a vertical slope. Thus, when we are trying to find when the slope is vertical, (parallel to the y axis), we set the denominator equal to 0, which means that the derivative must be undefined (vertical slope). When we want to find the horizontal line, we set the numerator equal to zero, which means that the derivative must equal zero (horizontal slope).
  Button navigates to signup page
  (10 votes)
Medha Nagasubramanian
Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to Medha Nagasubramanian's post “How do you know that the ...”
How do you know that the initial curve is a circle?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(2 votes)
Answer
- kubleeka
  Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to kubleeka's post “It isn't a circle, but it...”
  It isn't a circle, but it is a closed loop. You can see this if you parameterize the curve as
  
  x(t)=4cos(t)-3
  y(t)=√|4sin(t)| ·sin(t)/|sin(t)|
  
  The sin(t)/|sin(t)| factor makes y(t) negative when sin(t) is negative, so that you get both halves of the loop.
  
  Because we've expressed the curve in terms of sine and cosine, periodic functions, a particle tracing the path of the curve will repeat every 2π. Because the path repeats, it must form a loop.
  Comment on kubleeka's post “It isn't a circle, but it...”
  (2 votes)
Beqa Rioni
Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to Beqa Rioni's post “If the question is: "Writ...”
If the question is: "Write the equation of the horizontal line that is tangent to the curve and is above the x-axis", shouldn't the answer be: "y = x + 2", no the "y = 2" ?
Button navigates to signup pageComment on Beqa Rioni's post “If the question is: "Writ...”
(2 votes)
Answer
Cade McManus
Posted 2 years ago. Direct link to Cade McManus's post “Sal chooses to solve for ...”
Sal chooses to solve for 0 using the value of the dy/dx, rather than finding the derivative of the whole curve and solving from there.

Is this because if the answer is meant to be a horizontal line we only need to care about how the y-value of the derivative changes?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(1 vote)
Answer
- kaikycintra
  Posted a year ago. Direct link to kaikycintra's post “The derivative of the who...”
  The derivative of the whole curve is dy/dx, its equation gives us the slope of the curve when it is given values of x and y. That means making it equal to 0 shows us the values we need to input to find the points on the curve where the slope is 0, which is a horizontal line.
  Button navigates to signup page
  (1 vote)
Joseph Esparza
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Joseph Esparza's post “why did he disregard the ...”
why did he disregard the -28?
2:22
Button navigates to signup pageComment on Joseph Esparza's post “why did he disregard the ...”
(0 votes)
Answer
- obiwan kenobi
  Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to obiwan kenobi's post “He did not, 9-18 is equal...”
  He did not, 9-18 is equal to -9. Hope this helps!
  Button navigates to signup page
  (0 votes)

Video transcript

- [Instructor] We're told to consider the curve given by the equation. They give this equation. It can be shown that the derivative of y with respect to x is equal to this expression, and you could figure that out with just some implicit differentiation and then solving for the derivative of y with respect to x. We've done that in other videos. Write the equation of the horizontal line that is tangent to the curve and is above the x-axis. Pause this video, and see if you can have a go at it. So let's just make sure we're visualizing this right. So let me just draw a quick and dirty diagram. If that's my y-axis, this is my x-axis. I don't know exactly what that curve looks like, but imagine you have some type of a curve that looks something like this. Well, there would be two tangent lines that are horizontal based on how I've drawn it. One might be right over there, so it might be like there. And then another one might be maybe right over here. And they want the equation of the horizontal line that is tangent to the curve and is above the x-axis. So what do we know? What is true if this tangent line is horizontal? Well, that tells us that, at this point, dy/dx is equal to zero. In fact, that would be true at both of these points. And we know what dy/dx is. We know that the derivative of y with respect to x is equal to negative two times x plus three over four y to the third power for any x and y. And so when will this equal zero? Well, it's going to equal zero when our numerator is equal to zero and our denominator isn't. So when is our numerator going to be zero? When x is equal to negative three. So when x is equal to negative three, the derivative is equal to zero. So what is going to be the corresponding y value when x is equal to negative three? And, if we know that, well, this equation is just going to be y is equal to something. It's going to be that y value. Well, to figure that out, we just take this x equals negative three, substitute it back into our original equation, and then solve for y. So let's do that. So it's going to be negative three squared plus y to the fourth plus six times negative three is equal to seven. This is nine. This is negative 18. And so we're going to get y to the fourth minus nine is equal to seven, or, adding nine to both sides, we get y to the fourth power is equal to 16. And this would tell us that y is going to be equal to plus or minus two. Well, there would be then two horizontal lines. One would be y is equal to two. The other is y is equal to negative two. But they want us, the equation of the horizontal line that is tangent to the curve and is above the x-axis, so only this one is going to be above the x-axis. And we're done. It's going to be y is equal to two.