Main content
AP®︎/College Biology
Course: AP®︎/College Biology > Unit 5
Lesson 3: Non-Mendelian genetics- Variations on Mendel's laws (overview)
- Thomas Hunt Morgan and fruit flies
- The chromosomal basis of inheritance
- X-linked inheritance
- Genetic linkage & mapping
- Pedigree for determining probability of exhibiting sex linked recessive trait
- Pedigrees review
- Extranuclear inheritance 1
- Inheritance of mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA
- Non-Mendelian genetics
© 2023 Khan AcademyTerms of usePrivacy PolicyCookie Notice
Thomas Hunt Morgan and fruit flies
Thomas Hunt Morgan's pioneering fruit fly work that helped validate the chromosomal theory of inheritance.
Want to join the conversation?
- why is this sex linked trait found on the x chromosome and not the y? if all the guy flies have it, wouldn't it be logical to assume that this sex linked trait was found on the y chromosome?? i can't wrap my mind around why it is found on the x chromosome..(24 votes)
- This is a little bit of a confusing topic, so I hope I can help! First we need to remember that males are XY (X from mom, Y from dad) and females are XX (and X from both mom and dad). You can tell it IS X linked because there are red eyed males being produced in the F2 generation. If it was Y-linked, then ALL of the males would be white eyed because the dad (who has white eyes, AKA the "mutation") will give his only Y to make a male "baby fly". Now, I assume you're wondering how come there are no white eyed females if it is X-linked!? This is because females have TWO copies of the X chromosome. When mom and dad cross, baby girl fly will get ONE X from mom and dads ONLY X. That second X from mom will block or mask the "defective or mutated" gene from dad. NOW If the mother was a carrier; say XwX, and dad had white eyes XwY, and the baby girl fly inherited the mother Xw chromosome not the normal X, then her genotype would be XwXw, and THEN she would have white eyes. But as you can see from the experiment itself that isn't quite likely to happen :) I really hope that helped, and please don't hesitate to comment back if you're still stuck!(37 votes)
- Is it possible for there to be a white-eyed female in later generations? It seems possible when a white-eyed male breeds with a red-eyed female carrying a white-eyed gene.(10 votes)
- Yup! It's possible, but very unlikely as the female fly has to inherit Xw, the white eye allele, from BOTH parents, whereas for male flies, they only need to inherit ONE Xw gene to be white-eyed.(As males have sex chromosome of XY, but XX for females as I'm sure you know)(6 votes)
- How did Thomas Hunt Morgan identify each fruit fly? How could he tell that they were male or female, or if their eye colour was different, when they are such small bugs?(5 votes)
- He used a microscope to inspect his fruit flies in the early 1900's. Microscopes were invented in the 1600's. Giambattista Odierna originally described fly eyes in 1644, but it took later discoveries in science and years of hard work by Morgan to connect fly eye color with genes on chromosomes.(12 votes)
- Are y linked chromosomes possible? If so, that would mean that only the males are affected right?(3 votes)
- Do you mean Y-linked phenotypes?
These are uncommon§ due to the small size of the Y chromosome, but do exist.
For example, there is a strain of lab rats in which a component of high blood pressure (hypertension) is Y-linked.
You can read more about this here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y_linkage
§Note: Except for male sexual traits, of course!(6 votes)
- I have heard of sex linked dominant traits affecting the females but not the males. I would think that X linked dominant traits would show up equally in males and females. So why wouldn't the males be affected but the females would? It doesn't make any sense to me.(3 votes)
- It would help if you could give an example of a trait you heard.
But such expression profiles are possible. Certain genes responsible for hairiness are present on the X chromosome but are expressed only when that X chromosome is in a male because the activation and expression of these genes require several inputs, like certain hormones at certain specific developmental stages all of which are different for males and females due to the presence of Y chromosome in males. Have a look at a SRY region in the chromosome for more details on sexual dimorphism. Even some genes for male reproductive organs are on the X chromosome.
Similarly, the presence of female hormones, or the absence of male hormones might be required for certain genes to be expressed, making them X linked and still only expressed in women.(2 votes)
- Why is Xw+Y allelic pair not considered as hemizygous but as heterozygous?(2 votes)
- The white allele in an Xᵂ Y (male) fly is hemizygous, where did you hear otherwise?(3 votes)
- What happens when a white-eyed male is crossed with a heterozygous red-eyed female carring an allele of white-eyed?(2 votes)
- Offspring:
XwXw+, XwXw, Xw+Y, XwY
25% red-eyed female, 25% white eyed female, 25% red-eyed male, 25% white eyed male.(2 votes)
- I'm sorry for my ignorance of scientific experiment related knowledge for asking this silly question, but how did he do his experiments? In what kind of jar did he put his fruit flies? I assume when he discovered the male mutant fly in the F1 generation he put it in another jar and fill it with the normal females for the cross to happen, that means he needed to open the first jar, how was it possible that the other flies didn't fly away?!(1 vote)
- Fruit flies are easy to anesthetize typically by filling the container with CO2.(3 votes)
- How did Morgan eliminate for the possibility that the recessive white-eye gene might also be located on Y chromosome? If we assume that Y chromosome also contains a recessive allele for white-eyes, the F2 generation would still contain the 3:1 ratio, and would be expressed in male flies only. What am I missing?(1 vote)
- If that were true then how would you explain the result of the cross shown on the right around? Remember the X and Y are not homologous, so you generally§ won't have the same gene on both chromosomes. 9:00
You could hypothesize an allele on the Y that resulted in white eye-color, (maybe it encodes a protein that interferes with making the red pigment), but can you draw a Punnett square for this cross with that white-eyed allele on the Y chromosome and get the same results?
Does that help?
§ADDENDUM: Doesn't include any genes in the "pseudoautosomal region" (PAR).(3 votes)
- What if a white eyed male bred with a heterozygous female?
Wounder that not be this, Xw+ Xw Xw Y
Equaling female white eyes and a white eyed male?(1 vote)- I'm pretty sure that's what would happen because the way it seems is that the Xw allele is similar to that for color blindness. So an Xw-Xw female would be rare but not impossible.(2 votes)
Video transcript
- [Voiceover] Where we
left off in the last video we were in 1902, 1903,
and Mendelian genetics had been rediscovered at
the turn of the century and Boveri and Sutton,
independently, had proposed the chromosome theory,
that the chromosomes were the location for where
these inheritable factors that Mendel first talked
about, where they actually were located. But we talked about in that video that that was just a theory. This was based on some
observations of meiosis and seeing how chromosomes behaved, and they seemed to
behave in analogous ways to some of these inheritable factors but they really didn't
have good cellular proof that chromosomes indeed were the location for these inheritable factors. And we don't really start to get that until we start looking at the
work of Thomas Hunt Morgan. Now 1908, he decides to study fruit flies. So why does he wanna study fruit flies? If you've ever seen a fruit fly, they're very very very small. So you could actually put a
ton of fruit flies in one jar. So, that's convenient. You oftentimes don't think
about the practical logistics of science, but you could
put a lot in one jar. They were actually cheap,
and that's another practical concern of science, is you
don't always have a lot of resources to do your work. And they had short lives,
and they reproduced a lot so you could very quickly
get many many offspring and many many generations
if you wanted to study how the different traits were passed on or not passed on. And so he spent some time,
he started this in 1908 working with the fruit flies. And he kept breeding them,
in search for some type of a mutant trait. In general when you look
at traits in a species, the wild type, let me write this down, the wild type is the one
that's typically seen, while the mutant trait is
something that seems unusual. And after two years he finally
discovers a mutant trait in his fruit flies. He finds a white-eyed male. So this is the white-eyed
male right over here. He says oh, okay, now this is interesting. Let me take this white-eyed
male and begin to cross it with other, well, with the females. And you say well how
does this actually occur? Well, what you do is you
take a jar full of females and you put the white-eyed male in there and then the crossing happens. And what was interesting
was the inheritance pattern that he saw for this white-eyed trait. Because you have the
parent generation here, but then in the F1 generation all of the females were red-eyed and all of the males were red-eyed. And so just off of that first
generation it wasn't clear that anything interesting was going on. But then, when he crossed
these to each other, and I know what some of
you all are thinking, wait, aren't they all brothers
and sisters being crossed to each other? Ah, well, yeah, they were
probably half brothers and sisters if they came from different mothers, but some of them could have
been brothers and sisters, but yes, that's what
people are talking about when they're crossing the F1 generation. But when they crossed
these with each other, he saw a pretty interesting pattern. He saw a three to one ratio
of red eyes to white eyes, so for every four fruit
flies he would see, let me underline these, he
would see three red-eyed and he would see one white-eyed. So the white-eyed, the white-eyed trait makes a reappearance, which in
and of itself is interesting. It shows that this can
be passed on genetically. And that's interesting
because this was a mutant that just showed up after he
did many many many many many generations of observations. But what was even more
interesting about this three to one ratio, and that
three to one was something that popped up a lot
in Mendelian genetics, but what was even more
interesting was that he only observed, he only
observed the white eyes in the males in this F2 generation, in this second generation of
the crosses right over there. And so you're thinking,
well, why is that a big deal? Well, he was a pretty astute guy, and he says well look, if I'm
only seeing it in the males, and it's not like he only
got four offspring here in the ratio, he may have
had hundreds of them, but it was in the ratio
of two red-eyed females for every one red-eyed male,
for every one white-eyed male. And so across these hundreds
of, in this generation, he only observed the
white eyes on the males. And he said, hm, maybe
this is in some way related to the chromosome that determines sex. And so what he was able to do is say, well, let's just assume that it is. Let's assume that that
trait, that mutant allele, that mutant variation of
the gene for eye color, let's assume it's carried
on the x chromosome. And so the genotype for
that first mutant fly, that white-eyed male that he found, we could call it, and this is the notation that people typically use,
because this is a gene that we're assuming sits
on a, it's sex-linked, it sits on a sex chromosome,
in this case the x chromosome, the way that you would
specify the genotype of that white-eyed male is,
well on his x chromosome, he had the white variation,
he had the white allele, the white variation of that gene, and then on his y chromosome
he had no variation for that gene. So we assume that it's
only contained on the, only on the x chromosome. You've probably heard of
heterozygous or homozygous, well this is a case
where you're hemizygous, you only have a version of the allele on one of your two
chromosomes, one of the two that you've gotten from
each of your parents. So this would be the genotype right here of the white-eyed male. The genotype for the red-eyed female is specified by, so it's
on the x chromosome, and the females have two x chromosomes, just like in the situation for humans, so on each of the x chromosomes, we assume that the females
start off with the red allele, and the red allele, the
notation is the w +, w +. And you might say, well why
don't we just use the letter r? Well, we could have, but the
general convention in genetics is to use to letter of the
first mutant type discovered for that gene, and then to
use this little plus type for the wild type. So the wild type is the
red eyes, and then w, which is the mutant
discovered for this gene, is the first mutant allele, that we do so we name it after that white, so this is the white, the white allele, and these right here, these
represent the red alleles. So these are the genotype
of the red-eyed female. And so, when you cross
that first generation well, the white-eyed male, he can either, he'll either produce sperm
that have the x chromosome in it, which is going
to contain the allele, or sperm which have
the y chromosome in it, which is not going to contain the allele, and the red-eyed female, well
they produce eggs either way, either which of these x
chromosomes they contribute, they're both going to
have the wild type allele. And we can see how this crosses. You could get an x from both parents. If you get an x from both parents you're going to be female,
because you're going to be xx, and each of these females,
since you've got one wild type and one mutant type, and
the wild type turns out to be dominant, they still
show, their phenotype is still red eyes, they
still have red eyes. But now they are heterozygotes,
they are carrying the white allele. Now the male offspring right over here, well, in order to be male,
they got the y chromosome from their dad, so they're not able to get that white allele, and they
get the red, the wild type, from their mom. And you could see it here, and
this is why all of the males in that first generation were red. They only got one copy of the allele from their wild type mother. But then what was interesting
is the crosses that you see in that next generation. If you took these red-eyed females that we already established,
that these are all going to be heterozygotes,
and so you can see they have the red allele and
they have the white allele. And you cross that with red-eyed males. You cross it with red-eyed males, what is going to happen? Well, the females in this generation, in order to be female you
have to get an x from your mom and your dad, and so they
get an x from their dad which has the wild type there, the dominant red allele, and so regardless of which
one they got from their mom, they're still going to
be red-eyed females. Some of them might be homozygotes, some of them might be heterozygotes. But now we see something
interesting happening in the males. You could have heterozygote
male, male flies here, where they got the x from,
where they got the red x from their mom. Or you could get the
hemizygous white-eyed males, where they got the white
allele, the white x, from their mom. And this is the exact observation that Morgan made. So it was a very interesting
thing that he was able to see. He started breeding these
in 1908, he started breeding these flies in 1908. It wasn't until a couple of
years that he finally found that first mutant white-eyed male and it was in 1910 and
1911 that he publishes these discoveries in Nature. And the reason why this is a big deal is he says, look, this is, my observations are completely consistent with
this eye trait, this gene, being on the x chromosome. So he was able to show a
direct linkage between, in this case, sex chromosomes
and these heritable factors that Mendel first talked about. And he would go on and his
students that he worked with would go on to study this
for many many many many years and he actually ends up getting
a nobel prize for this work. And this is a big deal, because
he's finally able to draw pretty substantive connections
between these heritable factors Mendel, this
theory of Boveri and Sutton that maybe chromosomes
have something to do with these inheritable factors, and he's showing that
this is actually the case, these sex chromosomes
seem to carry the trait, or in this particular
case, the x sex chromosome seems to carry the gene for eye color in these fruit flies.