Main content
Cosmology and astronomy
Course: Cosmology and astronomy > Unit 3
Lesson 2: Seismic waves and how we know earth's structureRefraction of seismic waves
Refraction of Seismic Waves. Created by Sal Khan.
Want to join the conversation?
- When P-Waves get on the side of the earth opposite to the side they came from, wouldn't they start refracting the other way since the material that they are going through is now getting less dense?(38 votes)
- Not sure about "major changes have already occured". Why isn't the refraction symmetric? (it would refract the same amount coming up the same amount it refracted on the way down).(5 votes)
- Would the car not travel to the right? The front left wheel enters the denser medium first, so it travels slower while the other wheels in the less dense medium move faster. Wouldn't this make it move right?6:58(17 votes)
- I was confused about this as well, until I watched these videos again. Apparently a P-wave moves faster in denser material, therefore as it moves down it curves to the left.(14 votes)
- Regarding your last contextualisation where the earth is simply denser in the center, why don't the waves get an inverted refraction (fast to slow) at the end of its curve when it gets from denser material (center of the earth) to lighter material (outer crust) ? Is it because they reach a stable motion, perpendicular to the layers?(12 votes)
- I am slightly confused in the fact that waves travel faster in material that is more dense. This seems to be counter-intuitive. Can anyone explain more clearly how this happens?(7 votes)
- At around, Sal said that the seismic waves would go in a curve if in a particular angle. But won't the seismic waves eventually material that isn't that dense (the crust)? Which would mean that the the waves wouldn't go the way Sal actually mentioned? 8:50(4 votes)
- Technically speaking yes, Sal just simplified it so that we could understand the physics of it.(1 vote)
What would happen if the car traveled down the center of the fast and slow medium? Which way would it turn?(4 votes)- in the direction of the slow medium because the wheels on the fast medium are going faster turning the car in the direction of the slow medium. (more at) 2:55(2 votes)
- you show the example if you have a slow medium and a fast medium, but what if you have a (wait for it) ..... medium medium!(3 votes)
- Why does the P-wave from the earthquake keep refracting to a higher angle even when it starts to move away from the core, into less dense material? (Drawing at) 8:40(2 votes)
- On about- 3:50wouldn't the top "car" go towards the bottom? 4:00(2 votes)
- At, Sal was talking about slow mediums and fast mediums. What does he mean by "medium"?? 0:19(1 vote)
- The medium is the material through which the wave is propagating.(4 votes)
Video transcript
I want to do a quick
primer on refraction. And our focus here is going
to be on the seismic waves, but the principles,
how things refract when they go from a
fast to a slow medium or a slow to a fast
medium, It's actually the same as you would see when
you're studying light waves or actually any type of wave. So let's think about
it a little bit. So let's say I have a slow
medium right over here. And let's say I have a fast
medium right over here. And let's say, just
so we can travel through both solid and
liquids, let's think about maybe P-waves. And a slow medium could be
maybe some type of liquid, and our fast medium could
be some type of solid. So let me draw the
boundary right over here. So if I have a P-wave. Let's say it's going
through the water, and it's going right
perpendicular to the boundary. It will then just continue
to travel in the faster medium in the same
direction if it's going right at the boundary. And it'll just travel
faster in the faster medium. And that's because
that faster medium is going to be more
dense, and the molecules are going to bump into
each other faster. In the same amount of time
kind of the chain reaction is going to be
able travel further because they are
more closely packed and they rebound faster than
it would in the slow medium. So that's obviously no
refraction is going on. It has not been deflected. And just as a bit of reminder,
in general, refraction is when a wave gets deflected. Reflection is when
it bounces back. Refraction is when it gets
deflected a little bit. Let me just make that clear. So if I have some
type of boundary here, and I have a wave that bounces
off, that's reflection. But if the wave goes
through the boundary and just gets bent a little
bit, its direction changes, that is refraction. That's what we're talking about. So clearly so far this P-wave
has not been refracted. But if this P-wave comes in
at an angle-- so let's make this P-wave wave come in at an
angle-- what's going to happen is, and the way you
should think about it-- and it's the easiest way to
think about which direction will be refracted, or at least
the way I think about it, is literally I imagine some type
of vehicle with wheels on it. So this is the top
view of my vehicle. So if I have some type of
vehicle, and the wheels will be able to move
slowly in this medium. You could kind of view
it as it's kind of on mud so it doesn't get good
traction, and then the fast medium maybe it's a
road so it gets good traction, it could move faster. So what's going to happen
when the vehicle gets to the boundary? Well, this bottom right wheel is
going to go on the fast medium before any of the
other wheels do. So it's going to get
the traction first. These wheels on the left side
of the vehicle, these wheels right here, these are still
going to be stuck in the mud. So what's going to happen is
this wheel right over here is moving faster,
so it's essentially going to be able to
turn the vehicle. These guys are still
stuck in the mud. And so you fast
forward a little bit, the direction of the
vehicle will change. And so the vehicle will now
move in a direction something like this. The same thing would
happen in a wave. If the P-wave is approaching
the boundary like this, and something
analogous to this is happening at the
molecular level. You can kind of view it
as even billiard balls, and maybe they're kind
of hitting each other. Well, I won't go into that,
because that can kind of get confusing depending
on the different cases and the different boundaries. But this is the easiest
way to think about it, and which direction
it will refract. And hopefully it makes a
little bit of intuitive sense. And so when you go from a slow
to a fast medium our P-wave its angle would accentuate
in that direction. If you went from the fast medium
to the slow medium, once again, you can just go through the
same thought experiment. So let's say you have our
wave coming in like that. Draw the car. Visualize the car here. Visualize the car right here. And you'd say, well,
look, this tire's going to get stuck in the mud,
because it was on the road. Now, this top tire right over
here is get stuck in the mud first. So it's going to
be moving slower. So these tires are going
to be able to move faster. So the vehicle is going to turn. So you'll be refracted in a
direction like that when you're going from the fast
to the slow medium. So that's just a primer
on refraction generally. Now, let's think
about what would happen when sound waves are
traveling through the Earth. And this will help inform
us of, essentially, how do we figure out what the
actual structure of the Earth is. So if the Earth was just made
up of some uniform material and you had an earthquake right
here on Earth, maybe a little bit below the surface. So it's happening in the
crust, but a little bit below the surface of the Earth. If Earth was of
uniform density, if it was all the same material, let's
just think about the P-waves. Because P-waves can
travel in anything. Let's think about how
those P-waves would travel. Well, they would just
go in straight lines. There's nothing that
would refract the P-waves. They would just go in straight
lines radially outward from where the
earthquake occurred. Now, at a first
approximation, we know that as we go deeper
and deeper into Earth there's more and
more rock above that. The weight of that rock is
kind of compressing the rock below it. So you get higher
and higher pressures and higher and higher densities. So this is a uniform Earth. But let's imagine
an Earth that's made up of uniform material,
that's all solid, a completely solid Earth, but one where
the density is constantly increasing as you go down. So let's just think
about it before we go into the continuous case. Because we're talking about
the density as you go deeper, it's just getting
continuously more dense, let's think about
the discrete case, where we have the
least dense layer. So let me draw it
right over here. So let's say this is the
surface of the Earth. This is least dense. Then let's say you have
another layer over here that is more dense. So this is more dense. Let's say you have another
layer that's even more dense. So you have another layer over
here that's even more dense. And then let's do
one more layer. Let's do this layer here,
this is the densest layer. So in general, your
P-wave, your seismic wave, is going to travel faster
in denser material. So it's going to travel
the fastest here, then here, then here. It's going to travel the slowest
in this least dense material. So if you're coming
in at an angle let's think about
what's going to happen. So let's say you have
your P-wave coming in at an angle like this. So it's going straight through
the least dense material. Let me do a slightly
shallower angle. So let's say it's like that. What's going to
happen when it goes into the more dense material? So once again, let's
imagine our little car. So this tire's going
to be able to go faster before the tires
on the other side. So the car is going to
be deflected to the left, to the down left. So now it's going
to travel like this. So it's now going to
travel something like this. Now, what's going to
happen at this boundary? Once again, imagine the car. This tire right here is going
to be able to travel faster before the other tire, so
it'll be deflected even more in that direction. Then we go, and we go
to the densest material. Once again, the tires on
kind of the bottom side when we look at this
way are going to be able to move faster
before the other tire. So we're going to get
deflected even more. So you see, as you go from
least dense material to more dense material you're
kind of curving outward. So if this was
continuous, if you had a kind of a continuous
structure, where as you go down it just gets more and
more dense as you go. So this is less dense, and
then it just continuously gets more dense. So this is the most
dense down here. How would the refraction look? Well, then it would just
be a continuous curve. It would look like this. Your P-wave would constantly
be refracted out like that. It would curve outwards. So this was the simplest
example where Earth is uniform. And that's pretty
easy to dismiss, that obviously things will get
denser because of more pressure down. So let's say we
assume another thing. We have a uniform Earth
in terms of composition, but let's say it gets denser. So denser at the center. Then how would the
P-waves travel, or how would any
seismic waves travel? Well, then if you have your
earthquake right over here, the ones that are
going straight down still would go straight down. Because we know
that we won't get refracted if we're kind
of going perpendicular to the change in medium, or
the change in boundaries. But things that are
coming at a slight angle, as they get deeper they're going
to get deflected more and more and more, and they're
going to be refracted outward just like we saw
in this example here. If they go on this
angle they're going to be refracted
outward like that. If they go here they're going to
be refracted outward like that. They're going to be
refracted outward like that. If you're here you're going to
be refracted outward like that. If you're here you're going to
be refracted outward like this. Now, what we're going to
do in the next few videos is use what we just
learned about refraction in the case of seismic waves--
and hopefully we learned it in this video-- and
how it would refract as we're going through ever
increasing denser material. We're going to use
that information to essentially try to figure
out the composition of the Earth based on what we've
actually observed.