Dr. Rishi Desai is a pediatric infectious disease physician and former epidemiologist with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
Want to join the conversation?
- At the end, Dr. Rishi said that for measles, you can take a vaccine (MMR) to prevent getting measles, but is there a vaccine for Ebola?(1 vote)
- Are there any diseases that have R nought 0? I don't mean eradicated diseases but current diseases that everyone has a vaccine for it.(3 votes)
- There is only one eradicated disease known to mankind so far---smallpox, with polio being a possible second sometime in the future. But to answer your question, yes, there are probably some obscure diseases with R0=0, but they have most likely all died out or will do so soon. However, technically, cancer or things like heart disease or mental illness have R0=0-<1. (Depending on genetic transmission)
As for the second part of your question, vaccine alone cannot ensure that the R0 becomes 0, because it would be very difficult to vaccinate every single person who could possibly be infected by the disease. Even the eradication of naturally-occurring smallpox did not result from global vaccination, although it was considered a possible strategy and attempted.(4 votes)
- It seemed that example D was the most infectious, but I just realized that the infectious period is also a factor. So measles, with R0=18, in WEEKS, is not necessarily as infectious as Ebola, with R0=2, in DAYS. Am I correct to come to this conclusion?(3 votes)
- Right. If you assume 1 day for C and 1 week for D, C will spread to an average of 18 people in a week, while 2^7 people, or 128 people, will be infected by each original case for D in a week, on average.(1 vote)
- What is the period of time needed for R nought? as There can be a difference between Decades and weeks when calculating it.(1 vote)
- You can make up the period of time for the R nought. For example, the R nought could equal 7/4 in 2 weeks, or 92/13 in 15 months. If you want to get two different periods to be the same, you could just divide one of the bigger numbers.(3 votes)
- If the Flu has a nought of 2, and other diseases have higher numbers (like measles has 18), then why is the flu more common than any of those other diseases?(3 votes)
- I'd say it's more common because of how easily you can get it; you can get it just from breathing it in.(0 votes)
- Lets say we had 10 people infected with Ebola, after a couple of weeks there would be 5 newly infected people, so, R0 would =2, and the disease would be spreading from person to person. Am I right?(1 vote)
- R-Nought is how many people each person will probably infect. So if you started with 10 people, you would expect to have 20 new cases after a couple weeks (so you would have 30 cases total).(3 votes)
- why is the abbreviation of R-nought RO instead of RN?(1 vote)
- I think its because, in medical terms, RN means something else so they couldn't abbreviated as RN.(2 votes)
- So, basically R nought is probability of contagiousness?(1 vote)
- [Voiceover] So, I put up the definition of R nought, and it's kind of a funny spelling, and the pronunciation of N-O-U-G-H-T is just N-O-T, not. So, what it means, and the definition is here, we're just going to go through, what it means is the number of new cases that an existing case generates on average. So, the way I think about it is just in math terms. If you have R nought, you can just take literally the new number of cases divided by the existing number, and that should give you the average, right? And then a couple of points here over the infectious period, and, of course, some infections can be infectious for let's say a few days, and some are going to last for years. In fact, some can last for decades, where you can still spread it, even 30 years after you first got it. And then, a susceptible population. What that refers to is kind of a not vaccinated population. So, not vaccinated. Or you can think of it as a group that has never seen this infection before. So, maybe they are folks that had never naturally gotten this infection either, but basically their immune systems are seeing it for the first time and are susceptible to making them sick. So for me, the easiest way to kind of think through this is to kind of just come up with some examples. And so, imagine you have four infections. I'm just going to arbitrarily name them A, B, C, D, right? So, four infections. And each of these infections, let's say we kind of go into a community, and we say, how many of you guys have these infections? And we find that each of them, just to make the numbers easy, they all start out with four people having each of these infections. Okay. So, we decide to go into the future. We say, all right, we're going to follow you up some point in the future, and it's going to depend on which infection. So, maybe this one we'll have to come back decades later, because this one is infectious for decades, so we have to give it an appropriate amount of time. This one, we can come back some weeks later. Maybe some days later over here. It can depend on each one, right? So, let's just, each one is dependent on how long it's infectious for. So, you come back at some time point in the future, and for A, you find out that this person gave it to somebody, and this person gave it to somebody, and these other two, right here, they actually didn't end up giving it to anybody, this infection. So you'd say, all right, well what is the R nought, right? So, the R nought is going to be new cases, which is two, over old cases, which is four, or existing cases. So, R nought equals 0.5 here. And what about B? Well, this one let's say you get two people over here. Let's say this person gives it to somebody, and this person also gives it to nobody. So again, you just count up the numbers. You say, well, okay, here we have four divided by four equals one. So again, it's an average. So, even though some people gave it to more and some people gave it to less, the average is going to be one. And for C, similar kind of thing. I can say, well let's say you have a few people getting it, maybe two over there, maybe one over here, and this person gives it to let's say three people, right? So, in total I've got four, five, six, seven, eight. Actually, let me make these numbers even nicer. So, let's just say we've got eight people total. So, R nought equals eight divided by four. We started with four. And in this case R nought equals two. And D, I'm just going to make this one like an almost ridiculous sounding, but let's say we have tons of people that get sick. So this one, for whatever reason, a lot of people when we come back a few weeks later, we see that just many many many people have gotten sick, and, of course, on average we're going to have to take the total number of people that we see here and just divide it by the number four. So, I'm just going to quickly scrawl this out. Let's see what we get here. I'm going to get up to-- I'm trying to get up to 72. Let's see if I just-- I don't want to overshoot that number. So, we've got 30. We've got 40, 50, 60, and then I've got to just do 72. So, this one, whoops. This one divided by five, what do you get? You get 72-- Sorry, divided by four rather. Seventy-two divided by four is going to give us 18, right? So, this one has an R nought of 18, and I wanted to visually show that to you, just so you can see kind of what that would look like. And so, so far this is all making sense, and we can say, okay, well, we don't have to worry about these first folks anymore, because we already followed them for as long as we needed to, right? So, they're not going to spread it anymore, because we made sure that we followed them for weeks or days or decades, whatever the infection requires, but now we're interested in these blue folks, right? So, we want to know, well how are they going to spread it? Let's start with this one right here. Let's say this person spreads it to a single person. This person spreads it to one-- Let's say one, one, and two, and this person sends it to nobody. Let's actually just quickly make sure I do the math here. So, this is at a future time point, even further in the future, I guess. And now, our R nought is-- Again, you have to think about new versus existing, right? So, existing we had two blue ones. So, we had two down here, and we have one new person here. So, our R nought value is going to stay fixed. That's kind of the idea I want to express. The R nought is not going to change. It's kind of a measure that we think is unique to a particular infection. So, four over four remains one. R nought over here I just said is not going to change. So, we can already kind of assume what's going to happen. It's going to be okay, well on average it's going to be two. So, maybe some less, some more, but overall it's going to be that number, right? So, we're going to get something like this, and that also kind of easily tells you how quickly it's going to spread. It's going to double every time you come back. So, every few days, if that's what this is, every set number of days it's going to double. So, you're going to say, okay, instead of we started with eight, and now we have 16. And over here, with this one over here, it's just going to be an enormous number, right? It's going to be 72 times 18, which equals-- I actually did the math here. It's 1296 cases that are new, and we started with 72. So, that's R nought of 18. So, I'm not going to draw that in, but just a lot, right? A lot of people. So, what you can already kind of see happening here is that when you have an R nought less than one, which is kind of the case here, you basically see that this is going to start dying out. So, this infection starts to die out, and it's almost gone already. We started with four. We only have really one person left with this infection. Over here, when R nought equals one, exactly one, it's going to be stable. So, kind of moving over time, you see that the same number of people, in this case four, are going to have the infection. And over here, when R nought is greater than one, and it depends on how much greater, it's going to spread. So, the infection is spreading. And this is why this number is so important, and it's helpful, and to add a little bit of context here, Ebola, for example, has got an R nought of about two. So, that was the example I had in mind when I wrote that down. And infection D, this is a little bit like measles. So measles, you can see, is much much more inclined to spread than Ebola, for example. All right. Now, so before I leave you feeling completely hopeless about this situation, because this looks pretty scary, the way that these infections are spreading, let me point out something. So, I don't want it to seem like you can't actually intervene, and, in fact, there's a few things we can do to reduce the spread of these infections that have these high R nought numbers. One of them would be to block transmissions. So, you can make sure that if you have a sick patient, they are isolated. If you have a healthy person that has to be around them, for example, let's say a nurse or a doctor or something, you can make sure that they're wearing protective clothing. So, you could isolate the patient. You can wear protective clothing. All these kinds of things help to block transmission, right? And, in addition, you can also think, okay, well, what if a person does actually get exposed to an infection? For example, let's say measles. This is actually a great example. And Ebola doesn't fit this second category, unfortunately, not yet, today being October 12th, but we have vaccines against measles, right? So, you can actually vaccinate people, and in the case of measles it would be MMR. So, measles is MMR vaccine, and if you actually use this vaccine, and it has a certain effectiveness, that effectiveness prevents a lot of folks that have had the vaccine from getting sick. And so, these are a couple of ways to reduce the spread of these very very infectious agents.