Main content
Course: Wireless Philosophy > Unit 8
Lesson 9: Proportionality in punishmentEvaluating the argument
Proportionality in Punishment:
Evaluate and discuss the argument presented in this video.
Suppose that, in the heat of the moment after years of bullying, Jerry punches his bully in the face and is arrested for assault. The typical sentence for intentional assault is five days in jail.
Is this a fair sentence for Jerry to receive for his crime?
Consider the following range of opinions on this question:
- Five days in jail is a fair sentence for this kind of crime, so that's the sentence Jerry should receive regardless of the circumstances of his crime.
- Five days in jail is a fair sentence for this kind of crime, but under these circumstances, Jerry should receive a lesser sentence.
- Five days in jail is a fair sentence for this kind of crime, but under these circumstances, Jerry should receive a harsher sentence.
- Five days in jail is an unfair sentence for this kind of crime, regardless of the circumstances.
Now, take some time - by yourself or with others - to reflect openly yet critically on this question. Where do YOU stand, and why?
Want to join the conversation?
Jerry shouldn't be arrested at all because he was just standing up for himself.(1 vote)